Don’t personalize political disagreement

By John Hood
Posted 10/7/19

RALEIGH — This column is not about Donald Trump. You’re welcome.

While the deterioration of our public discourse preceded the 2016 election, political polarization is a defining characteristic …

Sign up to keep reading — It's FREE!

In an effort to improve our website and enhance our local coverage, has switched to a membership model. Fill out the form below to create a free account. Once you're logged in, you can continue using the site as normal. You should remain logged in on your computer or device as long as you don’t clear your browser history/cookies.

Don’t personalize political disagreement


RALEIGH — This column is not about Donald Trump. You’re welcome.

While the deterioration of our public discourse preceded the 2016 election, political polarization is a defining characteristic of Trump’s presidency. Partisan Democrats see Trump’s imprint on most matters and find it highly objectionable. Partisan Republicans see something else: Trump as the victim of ceaseless attacks by his foes inside and outside government.

Another way of saying the same thing is that our national politics, at least, has become hyper-personalized. It’s not a sign of civic health. And it isn’t helping us tackle challenging issues.

The Pew Research Center recently published a fascinating new study about the problem. For example, rather than just asking all respondents how politicians in general ought to conduct themselves, the researchers randomly assigned respondents to three groups.

One was asked whether they thought it was very important for “elected officials to treat opponents with respect.” Given the president’s style, you might expect Republicans to view this question with more skepticism than Democrats, and you’d be right. But the gap wasn’t large: 68 percent of the overall sample, 63 percent of Republicans, and 72 percent of Democrats agreed it was very important.

To the other two groups, however, Pew presented a variant of the question. Some were asked whether it was very important for “Republican elected officials to treat Democratic elected officials with respect.” Democrats were far more likely to say yes (78 percent) than were Republicans (49 percent). Similarly, when the third group was asked about “Democratic elected officials” treating “Republican elected officials with respect,” far more Republican respondents (75 percent) than Democratic ones (49 percent) said yes.

That’s a finding about political perceptions rather than moral double-standards, I suspect. Both sides view their “team” as more-or-less following the rules while the other team breaks them. It makes them resentful.

Pew also asked respondents about substantive questions: raising the federal minimum wage to $15 an hour, substantially expanding walls along the border with Mexico, and banning “assault-style weapons.” Later in the survey, respondents were asked whether they would be willing to share their views about these topics at a small dinner party with people who disagreed with them and whom they had never met before.

Large majorities of both supporters (74 percent) and opponents (70 percent) of the minimum-wage hike said they’d talk about it. Sizable majorities also said they’d talk about the other issues. When asked if at the same dinner party they’d want to discuss their feelings about the president, however, 57 percent of Trump supporters and only 43 percent of Trump opponents said yes.

If we want to talk about controversial issues in a more useful way, we should all lean against the hyper-personalization of politics. Focus as much as possible on the substantive issues, not on personalities. Explore why you think what you think, and how others might have come to a different conclusion without being ignorant, foolish, or dishonest.

Such constructive engagement across political differences takes time, concentration, and active listening. You can’t do it if your head space is occupied by someone else.

John Hood (@JohnHoodNC) is chairman of the John Locke Foundation and appears on “NC SPIN,” broadcast statewide Fridays at 7:30 p.m. and Sundays at 12:30 p.m. on UNC-TV.


No comments on this story | Please log in to comment by clicking here
Please log in or register to add your comment